Fairway 74th St Café Menu
Welcome to Fairway 74th St Café, a delightful haven for sandwich lovers and brunch enthusiasts alike, located at 2131 Broadway, New York. This charming café specializes in an enticing array of dishes, including freshly made sandwiches, vibrant burgers, and wholesome breakfast options.
The menu highlights include the Fig & Goat Cheese Salad and the creamy Burrata Mozzarella Salad, both showcasing seasonal ingredients for a refreshing taste. For those desiring comfort food, the café also offers delicious sides such as Herb Parmesan Fries and Sweet Potato Wedges.
Pair your meal with a selection of craft beers like the Montauk Summer Ale for a perfect brunch experience. With options for delivery and takeout, Fairway 74th St Café makes indulging in their delectable offerings convenient and enjoyable.
ALL DAY BREAKFAST
SCRAMBLED EGGS
All Eggs and Omelets are served with a choice of Brioche, 7 Grain or Rye Toast.
DIABLO EGGS
Scrambled with Chorizo, Roasted Tomato & Jalapeo
Classic
2 Eggs with Bacon and Breakfast Potatoes. Served with a choice of Brioche, 9 Grain ,Wheat ,White or Rye Toast
HENRYS EGGS
Rustic Eggs with Breakfast Potatoes (Sunnyside-up baked in with potatoes, caramelized onion and rosemary)
Upper West Sider
Fairway Smoked Salmon, Eggs, Onions (scrambled together), Toasted Bagel
CORNED BEEF HASH
With a Fried Egg & Toast
Frittata Primavera
Asparagus, Peas, Mushrooms, Goat Cheese
MATZO BREI
Fried Eggs and Matzo. Served with 100% pure maple syrup and jelly.
STEAK AND EGGS
Pan Seared Skirt Steak With 2 Eggs Any Style, Home Fries and Toast
Fresh Herb
Fresh Herbs with Gruyere or Fetta Cheese Served with a choice of Brioche, 9 Grain or Rye Toast.
Mushroom Omelets
Medley of Fresh Mushrooms. Served with a choice of Brioche, 9 Grain or Rye Toast.
Florentine
Fresh Baby Spinach, Aged Cheddar, Cherry Tomatoes. Served with a choice of Brioche, 7 Grain or Rye Toast.
Ham & Gruyere
Cured Ham & Gruyere Cheese. Served with a choice of Brioche, 9 Grain or Rye Toast.
Buttermilk Pancakes
With 100% Vermont Maple Syrup
Belgian Waffles
Belgian Style with 100% Maple Syrup
Chicken & Waffles
Belgian style with buttermilk chicken breast & maple syrup & butter.
The Big Breakfast
With Bacon or Sausage & Eggs any Style and a choice of waffle or pancakes
BIG BREAKFAST WITH OLD FASHIONED SOUR CREAM WAFFLES
With Bacon or Sausage & Eggs any Style
Breakfast Burger
Pat La Frieda burger, over easy egg, maple bacon, cheddar cheese, avocado aioli, lettuce and tomato.
Breakfast Bacon ,Egg, And Cheese Sandwich
2 Fried Eggs, Bacon, American On Your choice if bread ,With a side of breakfast potatoes.
GLUTEN FREE SILVER DOLLAR PANCAKES
Made with Rice Flour, Served with 100% Vermont Maple Syrup
SMOKE SALMON GLUTEN FREE CREPE
Buckwheat Crepe with Smoked Salmon & Crme Fraiche
HAM & GRUYERE GLUTEN FREE CREPE
Buckwheat crepe with cured ham, egg and Gruyere cheese
BIG BREAKFAST WITH FLOURLESS PANCAKES
With Bacon or Sausage & Eggs any Style
STEEL CUT IRISH OATMEAL
With Brown Sugar, Blueberries.This Item is made with whole milk, no substitutions.
Gluten Free Batter Pancakes
Challah French Toast
Smoked Salmon Bagel
Fairway's famous smoked salmon open faced on an everything bagel, with cream cheese, red onion, tomato, capers, and scallions
Crispy Potato Latkes
Served with sour cream, apple sauce & chives
BLT
Smoked Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato, Mayo on Sourdough Toast and a side of house fries
Crispy Chicken BLT
Crispy Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo on sourdough bread with a choice of herb Parmesan Fries or salad
Chicken & Fig Sandwich
Toasted Fairway sourdough, grilled chicken breast, fig jam, spinach, brie cheese & house fries
Smoked Gouda and Cheddar Grilled Cheese
Fairway sourdough bread, grilled with cheddar cheese and smoked gouda cheese
Crab Cake Sandwich
Our lamb crab cake on brioche, tartar sauce, lettuce and tomato served with herbed sweet potato wedges
Classic Pastrami Reuben
Fairway sourdough rye, pastrami, Russian dressing, Kosher Dill pickle, sauerkraut & Swiss cheese
New York Deli Style Pastrami
Fairway sourdough rye, pastrami, deli style mustard, Kosher Dill pickle
New York Rodeo
Fairway French sourdough, beef brisket, coleslaw, Kosher Dill pickle, frizzled onions, BBQ sauce
Classic Turkey Club
Fairway sourdough, oven roasted turkey, deli style mustard, Kosher Dill pickle, mayo, Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, red onion & Colby Jack cheese
SANDWICHES
ENTREES
Maryland Lump Crab Cakes
2 jumbo lump crab cakes, sweet potato fries, house-made tartar sauce & coleslaw
Faroe Island Salmon
Served with Any Side
Chicken Milanese
Pan Fried Chicken Cutlet, Arugula, Roasted Tomatoes, Red Onion, Radicchio, House Vinaigrette, Balsamic Glaze
Steak Frites
Pat La Freida NY Strip Steak, Roasted Garlic Butter, Parmesan Herb Fries
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Gourmet Garage vodka sauce, fresh basil, grated Parmigiano Reggiano & whipped ricotta
1/2 Bell & Evans Chicken
Roasted & basted in pan jus with carrots, asparagus and popped fingerling potatoes
KOREAN SHORT RIB
With Grilled Bok Choy & Coconut Sticky Rice
SPAGHETTI CARBONARA
Guanciale, Egg Yolk, Pecorino Romano, Black Pepper
SKIRT STEAK TOSCANA
Marinated in Olive Oil, Garlic, Rosemary & Parmigiano Reggiano. Served With Parmesan Fries
PAN SEARED PORK CHOP
With apple rosemary butter and roasted potatoes
KOREAN FRIED CHICKEN
With roasted jalapeno succotash
Pasta Primavera
Asparagus, Sweet Peppers, Carrots, Zucchini, Yellow Squash, Sun Dried Tomato, Garlic, Cream Parmesan, Gluten Free Pasta.
Cacio e Pepe
With Fresh Spahetti
Churrasco Steak
Skirt Steak with Argentinian Chimichurri
Tomahawk Pork Chop
Espresso Rubbed Heritage Pork Chop, Served with Roasted Fingerling Potatoes and Baby Carrots
FIG & GOAT CHEESE SALAD
Arugula, Frisee, Goat Cheese, Crispy Prosciutto. Balsamic Vinaigrette, Roasted Fig
BURATTA MOZZARELLA SALAD
With Heirloom Tomato, Baby Arugula, Basil, Balsamic Glaze, Extra Virgin Olive Oil & Maldon Sea Salt
Chopped
Mixed Greens, Cucumber, Avocado, Yellow Beets, Tomato, Asparagus, House Vinaigrette. Please note this mixture cannot be modified.
SALMON NICOISE SALAD
Poached Salmon, Boston Lettuce, Potato, Bell Pepper, Cucumber, Haricot Verts, Tomato, Onion, Anchovy,Hardboiled Egg, Nicoise Olive, House Vinaigrette
TUNA NICOISE SALAD
Tuna, Boston Lettuce, Potato, Bell Pepper, Cucumber, Haricot Verts, Tomato, Onion, Anchovy,Hardboiled Egg, Nicoise Olive, House Vinaigrette
Caesar
Romaine, croutons, Parmigiano-Reggiano, and Caesar dressing
Acorn Squash Salad
Roasted Acorn Squash,Mixed Greens,Pistachio, Spicy Honey & Sunny side Up Egg
Fairway Cobb
Romaine, Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Blue Cheese, Tomato, Hardboiled Egg, and avocado dressing
CARROT GINGER SOUP (32 oz)
This Item requires heating. Carrots, Fresh Ginger, Orange Zest, Vegetable Stock
Vegetable Minestrone
A Hearty Blend of 17 Garden Fresh Vegetables
VEGETABLE MINESTRONE (32 oz)
This item requires heating. A Hearty Blend of 17 Garden Fresh Vegetables
MUSHROOM BISQUE
Portobello Mushrooms, Chicken Stock, Sweet Onions, Thyme, Cream, Black Truffle
BEEF BARLEY SOUP
Prime Beef, Cremini Mushrooms, Vegetables, Bone Broth
Classic Chicken MatzohBall Soup
Better Than Bubbies, Chicken, Vegetables, Dill
CHICKEN MATZOH BALL (32 oz)
This item requires heatingBetter Than Bubbies, Chicken, Vegetables, Dill
Soup Du Jour
Kale & Quinoa
Red onion, cucumber, tomato, Feta cheese, chickpeas, carrots & house vinaigrette
SOUPS & SALADS
BURGERS
Caf Classic
Fairway brioche bun, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion & sliced pickle
GEMINI (Her Majesty)
Our classic beef burger split in two, served on a seeded bun with American cheese, onion, shredded romaine lettuce, sliced pickle, Majesty Sauce, hand-cut house fries, coleslaw & pickle
TOMMYS TURKEY BURGER
Ground turkey served on a Brioche bun with arugula, roasted tomato, caramelized onion, brie, hand-cut house fries, coleslaw & pickle
MARYS LAMB BURGER
Spiced ground lamb on naan bread, Tzatziki with spinach, cucumber, tomato, red onion, herbs, hand-cut house fries, coleslaw & pickle
Your Way
Classic Beef or Turkey on a bun with lettuce, tomato, red onion, coleslaw, pickle and hand-cut house fries
TEX-MEX BURGER
Prime Beef Burger, Pico de Gallo, Guacamole, Pepper Jack Cheese, Chipotle Aioli, Lettuce
Truffle Shuffle
Wild mushrooms, scallions, Moliterno alTartufo (truffle Cheese), truffle garlicaioli
Patty Melt
English Muffin, Colby Jack cheese, caramelized onion & 74th ST caf secret sauce
Maple Onion Jam
Fairway brioche bun, Maple onion jam, brie, arugula & Applewood bacon
Mushroom Swiss
Fairway brioche bun, wild mushroom medley, Swiss cheese, scallion & garlic aioli
Margherita
San Marzano tomatoes, fresh Fairway mozzarella, salted mozzarella, basil & Fairway EVOO
QUATTRO STAGIONI PIZZA
California Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Fairway Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Artichoke, Mushroom, Olive, Prosciutto
DOPPELGNGER PIZZA
California Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Hot Sausage, Red Onion, Jalapeo, Caper, Gorgonzola Dolce, Basil, Chili Flake
THE MICHELANGELO PIZZA
Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil & Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Pepperoni, Sausage, Bell Pepper, Olive, Onion &Mushroom
Breakfast pizza
San Marzano tomatoes, fresh Fairway salted mozzarella, homemade maple bacon, egg, and 100% maple syrup
PROSCIUTTO & ARUGULA PIZZA
Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Fairway Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Aged Prosciutto & Baby Arugula
White Pizza
Mozzarella, ricotta, Parmigiano Reggiano, Fairway EVOO, Garlic, & chili flakes
Drunken Pizza
Vodka sauce, fresh Fairway Mozzarella Parmigiana Reggiano, Pepperoni, Basil, topped with Hot Honey
PIZZA
WEEKLY SPECIALS
CAESAR SALAD
Romaine, Croutons, House Made Caesar Dressing, Parmigiano Reggiano
CLASSIC GRILLED CHEESE
Cheddar, Gruyere, White Bread, Fries.
CAFE LOBSTER ROLL
CARDAMOM FRENCH TOAST
Cardamom, Cinnamon, Nutmeg, Fresh Berries, 100% Pure Maple Syrup
CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH
Homemade Roasted Chicken. Mayo & Celery on 7 Grain
HOMEMADE HOT CHOCOLATE
With Mini Marshmallows
HOT APPLE CIDER & APPLE CINNAMON DONUT
BRISKET N MASH
Classic braised beef brisket served with mashed potatoes
IMPOSSIBLE CHILI
IMPOSSIBLE plant based meat substitute, Red kidney beans, Sweet peppers, Onions & Spices, Served with Vegan multigrain chips
SNAPPER
Pan Fried Snapper Filet with Panko, Parmesan & Lemon Pepper. Served with Parmesan Grilled Asparagus.
BUBBIES BRISKET SANDWICH
Braised Brisket, Kettle Chips, Caramelized Onion, Horseradish Cream, Brioche
HEIRLOOM SHAKSHUKA
Poached eggs in spiced heirloom tomato sauce. With domestic feta cheese and toast
BREAKFAST BRUSSELS
Shaved Brussels Sprouts, Sweet Potato, Shallots, 1 Over Easy Egg, Creme Fraiche, Sunflower Seeds, Chives
CHOCOLATE BABKA
JELLY DOUGHNUT
CARROT GINGER SOUP
Carrots, Fresh Ginger, Orange Zest, Vegetable Stock
LOBSTER TACOS
2 tacos - Corn tortillas with real lobster salad, roasted corn, jalapenos, shaved lettuce, cilantro and lime. Served with potato chips.
SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
Plum Tomato, Pork, Beef, Pecorino Romano, Basil
MEATBALL PARM HERO
Classic Meatballs with Mozzarella & Provolone on a Portuguese Roll With Garlic Butter
CHICKEN LASANGNA
Ground Chicken. San Marzano Tomatoes, Onions, Parmesan, Mozzarella, Basil, Ricotta, Eggs & Herbs. Served With a Petit Side Salad
FRIED CHICKEN
Fairway seasoned Fried chicken. Fried Per order. Available in 4 or 8 piece.
Mac n Cheese
Classic creamy Mac and cheeseServed in a pound container.
SIDE OF PORK BACON
SIDE OF TURKEY BACON
SIDE PORK SAUSAGE
SIDE OF TURKEY SAUSAGE
SIDE OF BREAKFAST POTATOES
SIDE OF AVOCADO
SIDE BAGEL
BAGEL & CREAM CHEESE
TOASTED BAILEY
SIDE TOAST
CHOOSE BRIOCHE, 9 GRAIN, RYE
Herb Parmesan Fries
SWEET POTATO WEDGES SIDE
ONION RINGS
BROCCOLINI
GRILLED ASPARAGUS SIDE
ROASTED CARROTS SIDE
CREAMED SPINACH SIDE
STEAMED SPINACH SIDE
MASHED POTATOES SIDE
SIDE DILL PICKLE
Organic Granola
Greek Yogurt, Fresh Fruit & Honey
FRESH FRUIT PLATE
A Fresh Selection of Seasonal Fruits
HOUSE CUT FRENCH FRIES SIDE
COLE SLAW SIDE
GREEN & YELLOW SQUASH SIDE
PARMESAN FRIES SIDE
POLENTA FRIES
With Spicy Marinara Sauce
KALE & WILD MUSHROOM SIDE
MONTYS MAC & CHEESE SIDE
SAUTEE SPINACH SIDE
SPAGHETTI CAPRESE SIDE
Asparagus Parmesan Fries
With Gemini Sauce or Spicy Marinara
Scones
Danish
Muffins
Croissants
Side Eggs
Two eggs any style
Fruit Cup
Wild Rice
SIDES & EXTRAS
DESSERTS & PASTRIES
CLASSIC APPLE PIE
PECAN PIE
VERY BERRY PIE
CHEESECAKE
CORN MUFFIN
APPLE CRUMB MUFFIN
APPLE TURNOVER
CHEESE DANISH
BLONDE BROWNIE BITES (3)
ALMOND CROISSANT
CROISSANT
CLASSIC CHERRY PIE
Chocolate Ganache Cake
Red Velvet Cake
VANILLA VANILLA CAKE
VANILLA CHOCOLATE CAKE
COCONUT CUSTARD PIE
PUMPKIN MUFFIN
APPLE CINNAMON DONUT
CARAMEL PUMPKIN PIE SLICE
BY OVENLY
CARAMEL PUMPKIN PIE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
BLACK BOTTOM PECAN PIE SLICE
BY OVENLY
BLACK BOTTOM PECAN PIE WHOLE
BY OVENLY
APPLE PIE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
APPLE PIE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
CHEESECAKE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
NY BLACKOUT CAKE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
N.Y BLACKOUT CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
BROWNIE CHEESECAKE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
COCONUT CAKE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
COCONUT CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
BLUEBERRY CRUMB PIE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
BLUEBERRY CRUMBLE PIE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
CHERRY CRUMB PIE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
CHERRY CRUMBLE PIE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
RED VELVET CAKE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CASKES
RED VELVET CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
COCONUT CUSTARD PIE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
COCONUT CUSTARD PIE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
CARROT CAKE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
CARROT CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
TIRAMISU CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
CANNOLI CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
GIGGLE CHOCOLATE CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
TRIO MOUSSE CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
STRWBERRY SHORTCAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
CHOCOLATE CAKE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
PECAN PIE SLICE
BY: CAROUSEL CAKES
PUMPKIN PIE
BOSTON CREAM CAKE SLICE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
BOSTON CREAM CAKE WHOLE
BY CAROUSEL CAKES
Juniors Cheesecake with Strawberries
Tiramisu
Layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and creamy mascarpone, dusted with cocoa powder.
Black and White Chocolate Mousse Tart
Mini Dessert Bombs
Salted Carmel Cupcake
Chocolate Chip Cannoli Sandwich
Fairway Ice Cream
Scoops of your favorite Fairway flavors: strawberry, vanilla, and chocolate ice cream.
Bread Pudding With Vanilla Ice Cream
Warm, spiced bread pudding served with a scoop of creamy vanilla ice cream.
Strawberry & Blueberry Crisp
Blend of strawberries and blueberries with a crispy oat topping, served warm.
Nutella Pizza
Sweet pizza topped with rich Nutella and a sprinkle of powdered sugar
HOT APPLE CIDER
Coffee
12oz
Iced Coffee
16 OZ
Cappuccino
12oz.
ICED CAPPUCCINO
16 OZ
Caf Latte
12oz
ICED CAFE LATTE
16 OZ
LEMONADE (16oz)
FRESH BREWED UNSWEETENED ICED TEA (16oz)
ARNOLD PALMER (16oz)
1/2 Lemonade, 1/2 Iced Tea
LACROIX PAMPLEMOUSSE
12OZ
SMART WATER SPORT CAP
LACROIX CRAN RASPBERRY
12OZ
LACROIX PURE
12OZ
LACROIX LIME
12OZ
Fairway Orange Juice 16oz
A cup of freshly squeezed Fairway orange juice
MOTT'S 8oz APPLE JUICE
POLAND SPRING 120z
COCA COLA 4 oz
DIET COKE 8oz
SPRITE 4oz
Mexican Coke (12oz)
Boylans Gingerale
COCA COLA 12oz
Sprite
Coca Cola 16.9 oz
Coca Cola 1.5 Liter
Sprite 1.25 Liter
Diet Coke 16.9 oz
Diet Coke 1.25 Liter
LACROIX KIWI WATERMELON
12OZ
FRESH SQUEEZED ORANGE JUICE 12OZ
FRESH SQUEEZED ORANGE JUICE 16OZ
BLOOD ORANGE JUICE 16OZ
PINEAPPLE JUICE 12OZ
PINEAPPLE JUICE 16OZ
GRAPEFRUIT JUICE 12OZ
APPLE JUICE 12OZ
APPLE JUICE 16OZ
LACROIX TANGERINE
12OZ
Mexican Sprite (12oz)
Pelligrino (25.3oz)
LACROIX BLACKBERRY CUCUMBER
12OZ
ESSENTIA WATER
33.8OZ
MASH POMEGRANATE
20OZ
MASH GRAPEFRUIT
20OZ
FAIRWAY WATER 1L
1L
FIJI WATER 1L
1L
Box of Brew
Coke 12oz Btl
Sprite 12oz Btl
Saratoga Sparkling Water
Saratoga Still Water
BEVERAGES
Wine By the Bottle (Must be 21 to Purchase)
KOMBUCHA ORIGINAL
Must be 21 to purchase. 16OZ
2022 Muscadet Sevre Et Maine
Domaine De La Geraudrie
2022 Sauvignon Blanc
Hunky Dory
2021 Chardonnay
2021 Estate Riesling
Bottle
2022 Coteaux D'Aix En Provence Rose "Sabine"
2022 Orange 'Love You Bunches'
Bottle
2021 Chianti
Bottle - Red
2021 Pinot Noir
Prisma- Red
2020 Syrah
Gabrielskloof - Red, Bottle
2020 Cabernet Sauvignon
California, Grounded by Josh PhelpsBottle, Red
Montauk Summer Ale
Must be 21 to purchase.
Ommegang Nirvana IPA
Must be 21 to purchase.
Founders Porter
Must be 21 to purchase.
Brooklyn Ale
Must be 21 to purchase.
Sam Adams
Must be 21 to purchase.
Modelo Especial
Must be 21 to purchase.
Amstel Light
Must be 21 to purchase.
Stella Artois
Must be 21 to purchase.
Blue Moon
Must be 21 to purchase.
Guinness Draught Stout
Must be 21 to purchase.
Montauk Pilsner
Must be 21 to purchase. 5.4% ABV.
Heineken
Must be 21 to purchase. 5% ABV.
White Claw Hard Seltzer- MANGO
Must be 21 to purchase. 5% ABV.
Brooklyn Defender IPA
Must be 21 to purchase. 5.5% ABV.
Brooklyn Bel Air Sour
Must be 21 to purchase. 5.8% ABV.
Bronx Brewery - NO RESOLUTIONS IPA
Must be 21 to purchase. 7.6% ABV.
Coney Island Brewery - Mermaid Pilsner
Must be 21 to purchase. 5.2% ABV.
White Claw Hard Seltzer- RASPBERRY
Must be 21 to purchase.
White Claw Hard Seltzer- TANGERINE
Must be 21 to purchase.
White Claw Hard Seltzer- LIME
Must be 21 to purchase.
Brookyln Brewery
East IPA
